About Me

Name: Ron Pavellas
Biography
Loading...

Create Your Own Blog Find Other Townhall Blogs

Comments

Blog Roll

 
Literature, philosophy, music & travel

"Mass Collaboration" and Open Source Technology are "Flattening" Your World

Walt Mossberg writes technology columns for the Wall Street Journal, and his various writings can be seen online at his All Things Digital web site. He recently addressed "The Ideas Festival" of The Aspen Institute. Here is a YouTube video Mossberg's speech. Although his talk was mostly about the development of what he calls "the instrument formerly known as the cell phone," with specific and laudatory reference to the iPhone, I fixed on an analogy he made regarding the Internet. He predicted our perception of the Internet will be, in the near future, the same as we now perceive the electrical power grid that serves all developed countries. We don't even think about it; it's just there every time we plug something into it or turn on something already plugged into it. [Please click on any image for a closer view] I saw this video shortly before I finished reading Wikinomics by Tapscott and Williams. Mossberg's comment tied in neatly to the message of this book and that of The World is Flat, Release 3.0, by Thomas L. Friedman. Both books cite a signal event to underscore the thrust of their arguments: the decision, in year 2000, of Rob McEwen, former CEO of Goldcorp Inc., a Canadian company, to share all the highly proprietary geological data of his company over the Internet. He offered a prize of $575,000 to any geologist in the world who could tell Goldcorp where to drill, successfully, on the mining properties it held, based on the information his company's geologists had developed over years. It was a major success. To quote from Wikinomics, "One hundred dollars invested in the company (Goldcorp) in 1993 is worth over $3,000 today (early 2008)." To quote further from Wikinomics: "This new mode of innovation and value creation is called 'peer production,' or 'peering'—which describes what happens when masses of people and firms collaborate openly to drive innovation and growth in their industries." A footnote goes on to say that this term was coined by Yale professor Yochai Benkler. Another term used by the authors, "Mass collaboration", is used to mean the same thing, as well. (There are many neologisms and much jargon used in each of the two books discussed here). Well-known examples of "peering" or "mass collaboration" are "MySpace", YouTube," and "Wikipedia." (I often use two of these collaborative places in this blog). Skitter Graph of The Internet [Source] The major implication of our ability, through the Internet's information grid, to collaborate in such ways is the "Flattening" of the world, according to The World is Flat. My interpretation of the use of this word in this context is that the organizational hierarchies we are used to in our working lives, our educational lives and even our social lives, is crumbling and restructuring, "sideways." By this I mean that we, through the World Wide Web and our easy access to it via the Internet, are not constrained from connecting with anyone (with Internet access), anytime, in any part of the world. The power that flows from the possession of information is now shared by those who see the added value of sharing information, rather than hoarding and rationing it. Another, perhaps the other development that "flattens" (makes more available to everyone) our ability to access and use information, is the development of open-source technology. Anyone and everyone can be part of the development of information platforms that are freely used. Examples are the Linux operating system which competes with Windows and MAC OS, and the Mozilla Open Source Software Project which competes with Microsoft Internet Explorer and Apple's Safari. Linux and Mozilla are developed, continually, by its users; both entities are non-profit organizations, and the vast majority of their contributors are volunteers. I recently visited the trade show "World Water Week" in Stockholm. A major presenter at this forum was Akvo, a not-for profit "Open Source for Water and Sanitation." In its online literature, Akvo describes itself as "... like a Wikipedia, eBay and YouTube for water and sanitation projects, rolled into one." Its approach to developing and sharing information, and in promoting rapid and efficient deployment of funds and tools to water and sanitation projects around the world for those that do not have clean water or no sanitation, have earned Akvo significant funding from the Dutch government, among other "funding partners." Akvo is just one of many such open source projects, of myriad types, that are flattening our world and causing a major restructuring of how we get important work done, collaboratively. The further implication of this positive trend is that the Internet needs to remain unfettered by government regulation and bureaucratic barriers. Information is power; entrenched organizations, whether governments or business corporations, will want to garner, hoard and ration information, and access to it, for their own organizational purposes.
Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

"Fearless" Author Richard Zimler Visits Stockholm

A set of synchronicities has led me to write this entry to my journal. Several months ago the book discussion group to which I belong read The Search for Sana, by Richard Zimler. I wrote about it, in conjunction with two other books, in my weblog entry of 19 April 2008. In front of New York Stories English Bookshop Later, my friend Margaret Patane, owner of New York Stories English Bookshop, told me and others of the imminent arrival of Mr. Zimler to Stockholm for the purpose of promoting The Search for Sana which has recently been translated into Swedish. Margaret, through her friendly connection with the Stockholm Public Library's main branch-a short walk from her store-and through friendship with a person in my book group who is acquainted with the Swedish publisher of the book, became directly involved in Mr. Zimler's presentation at Stockholms Stadsbibliotek. Here is Margaret's blog announcement of the event. The event was well attended, and quite fulfilling for me as a writer-in-training. Here is Margaret's review of Mr. Zimler's presentation. I have a few more observations, below. Stockholm's Main Library, Stockholms Stadsbibliotek I have read many times of the need for a successful author to be "fearless." Mr. Zimler fulfills this criterion. There was certainty in my nervous system that Richard, as he prefers to be addressed, is WYSIWYG: "What You See Is What You Get". In answering the numerous questions proffered him after his fearlessly informative presentation, he seemed easily to consult, quickly, both his guts and his brains to give us honest, full responses. I felt I knew him, even without having had a private conversation with him. He confirmed for me what I saw of him in his Search for Sana, written in the first person and based in good measure on personal experience and research, as Richard explains in this video. Richard Zimler The other thing to say, before I move on to discuss another book by Zimler, is that Search for Sana, a good and valuable book, has not been published in the USA. I was astounded to learn this from Richard in his presentation, and I remarked in the Q&A session that it needs to be read in the USA. There is much lucidly presented in the book that is soulfully and factually instructive to both sides (as if there were only two) of issues and dilemmas facing Israelis and Palestinians. I wish I had the power to convince a USA publisher to look carefully at Search for Sana. His book was published in English by Constable & Robinson Ltd., of London. The day after Richard's presentation at the library, he appeared at Margaret's bookshop to chat and sign additional books for sale, including his Hunting Midnight. I bought one of the signed copies of Hunting Midnight a few hours after Richard had left the bookshop, heading for Stockholm's major airport, Arlanda (ARN), to resume his travels. Please click on the image for clearer detail There are reviews of the book available on the Internet, including this one, and another one here. These reviewers are quite thorough so I will add only what I think may be a unique perception about it. This book, in addition to being suitable for adult readers, falls in great measure into the same realms as Uncle Tom's Cabin and tales by The Brothers Grimm which books I read in my preteen years. None of the violence depicted in this book is gratuitous nor unduly detailed. There is no more violence or allusion to violence than is found in Grimm's tales. Further, the parts depicting wickedness are balanced by loving, if sometimes difficult, relationships among the main and some secondary characters. Richard Zimler has a unique voice in current literature. I look forward to reading his The last Kabbalist of Lisbon, a widely acclaimed book and one that has made him a celebrity n Portugal, his home for almost two decades. Richard was born on Long Island, New York.
Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

Liberty and Freedom

I have been reading the Englishman John Stuart Mills's essay On Liberty, first published in 1859. Here is a taste:

Johm Stuart Mill, 1806-1873

The struggle between Liberty and Authority is the most conspicuous feature in...history, particularly in that of Greece, Rome, and England. But in old times this contest was between subjects, or some classes of subjects, and the Government. By Liberty, was meant protection against the tyranny of the political rulers. The rulers were conceived...as in a necessarily antagonistic position to the people whom they ruled...The aim, therefore, of patriots was to set limits to the power which the ruler should be suffered to exercise over the community; and this limitation is what they meant by liberty.

A current definition of both freedom and liberty shows that freedom accrues to the individual while liberty, as Mill points out, accrues to the community or general population of a polity:

'Freedom' (is) an exemption from control by some other person, or from arbitrary restriction of specific defined rights like Worship, or Speech. 'Liberty' (is) the sum of the rights possessed in common by the people of a community/state/nation as they apply to its government, and/or the expectation that a nation's people have of exemption from control by a foreign power. [Source]

Mill goes on to say: Some, whenever they see any good to be done, or evil to be remedied, would willingly instigate the government to undertake the business; while others prefer to bear almost any amount of social evil, rather than add one to the the departments of human interests amenable to government control.

This is exactly the observation I made to my late father in our sometimes heated political discussions. I drew a rough graph to illustrate my argument, then added a picture of a normal curve below it suggesting he mentally superimpose it on the graph:

[Please click on the image]


As with any ideal "normal" or "bell" curve, 68% of the things measured, in this case attitudes toward my assertedly dichotomous "safety/freedom" spectrum, will fall within the first standard deviation. Within this zone around 1/3 of the people will slightly or somewhat prefer safety to freedom and another 1/3 of the people will slightly or somewhat prefer freedom to safety. These are the people who can still talk with each other, in a reasonable tone, about their differences in viewpoint on how much control the government should be allowed over our personal freedom to act and speak, in order to protect us from others.

Following along this line of argument, an additional 28% of the population will fall into the second standard deviation. The people whose attitudes in this realm tend toward one value or the other (safety vs freedom), will have stronger preferences and will make strong, usually emotionally-laden, defense of their respective positions. In this realm 14% of the population will argue heatedly (as dad did) for safety over freedom (although he didn't see the dichotomy I see it), and 14% will argue heatedly for freedom over safety, as I did.

The remaining 4% of the population at the third standard deviation from the middle or mean, 2% at either end of the spectrum, are the outliers within whose ranks one may find the people who will resort to dangerous methods to assert their preference.

My basic point with dad was that these preferences, especially as one one deviates more from the middle of the normal curve, will not be reconciled among people who have opposing viewpoints. These values are too emotionally held to be altered by mere rational argument, on the one hand, or made more convincing by emotional appeal, on the other. It is ironic to me that dad often used to quote to me the following stanzas from William S. Gilbert's (of Gilbert & Sullivan) comic opera Iolanthe:

I often think it's comical/How nature does contrive
That every boy and every gal/That's born into the world alive
Is either a little Liberal/Or else a little Conservative

---

Taking an excursion into another realm to provide some blood for this wordy argument, I offer these:

Eleftheria i thanatos (Greek: "freedom or death") is the motto of the Hellenic Republic. It arose during the Greek War of Independence in the 1820s, where it was a war cry for the Greeks who rebelled against Ottoman rule. It was adopted after the Greek War of Independence. It is still in use today, and is symbolically evoked by the use of 9 stripes (for the nine syllables of the motto) in the Greek flag. The motto symbolized and still symbolizes the resolve of the people of Greece against Tyranny and oppression. [Source]

Among many other mysteries presented to the reader in The Magus, by John Fowles, is the problem of whether a man has the right even to enter into a contract that entails sacrificing some lives to spare others (even when the murder of three might save 80), which long and terrible scene ends with a Greek cry of "Eleftheria!" [Source]

---

The last words in today's blog are from John Stuart Mill's On Liberty:

...(T)he sole end for which mankind are (sic) warranted, individually or collectively, in interfering with the liberty of action of any other of their number, is self-protection. That the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own good, either physical or moral, is not a sufficient warrant. He cannot rightfully be compelled to do or forbear because it will be better for him to do so, because it will make him happier, because, in the opinion of others, to do so would be wise, or even right. These are good reasons for remonstrating with him, or reasoning with him, or persuading him, or entreating him, but not for compelling him, or visiting him with any evil in case he do otherwise. To justify that, the conduct from which it is desired to deter him must be calculated to produce evil to someone else. The only part of the conduct of any one, for which he is amenable to society, is that which concerns others. In the part which merely concerns himself, his independence is, of right, absolute. Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign.


[Please click on the image to get the full message]

Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

The EU Measures its Communicable Disease Status & Trends: First Report, for year 2005

In remarking to a new acquaintance, a writer who's also a working journalist, that I haven't been able to find disease statistics aggregated by EU countries, he promptly referred me to: The First Annual Epidemiological Report on Communicable Diseases in Europe, published by the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control, based at Solna, Sweden, in Stockholm County.


As a guy educated in public health, I was excited to have access to new information about disease patterns in the general area where I live (Sweden).

The World Health Organization (WHO) to which I had gone for information to write a previous blog was very informative and helpful, but not for aggregating EU information. So, apparently, the EU countries have organized to do this for themselves, with the first published result as reported and excerpted here.

I warn the reader that the published information under the first link, above, should be your official source for the work results of the ECDC. What follows is my formulation of the information presented in the report.













Please click on any image to see it in full and more clearly

The above two charts represent the summary findings of ECDC for the year 2005, and the trends over the 10 years ending 2005 for the communicable diseases "monitored and detected."

A look at the 2-page chart above shows several diseases increasing over the last 10 years, within the 28 European countries measured: Antimicrobial resistance infections (AMR), HIV, Chlamydia, Hepatitis C, Avian influenza, Legionnaire's disease, Campylobacteriosis, and Listeriosis. You can see about each of these diseases under their respective links, immediately above.


In that I live in Sweden, I am interested to know where Sweden stands in the trends for these diseases. It is quite low, compared to the averages of the other 27 European countries, but it is noticeably high in one, although still below the average: Chlamydia, a sexually transmitted infection.

This is from the Summary of the report: "It is of concern that three of the six diseases with the highest incidence in the EU are part of this group of diseases with rising/stable trends; rising trends are also observed for the two diseases with the highest crude incidence levels in the EU (Chlamydia infection and campylobacteriosis), but this could be also due to improved surveillance."

Here are more excerpts from the Summary:

"...(I)t can be concluded that at present the major communicable disease threats in the EU are the following:

Healthcare-associated infections, with or without antimicrobial-resistant pathogens. The most important disease threat in Europe is posed by the micro-organisms that have become resistant to antibiotics. Infections with such bacteria are a huge and rapidly growing problem in our hospitals, but also in more everyday infections in the community. Every year approximately three million people in the European Union catch a healthcare-associated infection, of whom approximately 50 000 die.

HIV infection. 28 044 new cases of HIV were reported in EU countries in 2005. The total number of people living with HIV in the EU is estimated to be around 700 000. Of these people, some 30% – around 200 000 – do not know they have HIV.

Pneumococcal infections. This is the main bacterial cause of respiratory tract infections, with high death rates (especially in young children and the elderly) when the infection is invasive (causing bacteraemia or meningitis). Effective vaccines against invasive disease are now available.

Influenza (pandemic potential as well as annual seasonal epidemics). Each winter, hundreds of thousands of people in the EU become seriously ill as a result of seasonal influenza. Of these, several thousand will die in an average influenza season, often unnecessarily as effective vaccines are available for those most at risk.

Tuberculosis. Nearly 60 000 cases of TB were reported in the 25 EU Member States in 2005. TB cases continue to rise among vulnerable groups such as migrants and HIV-positive people. Cases of drug-resistant TB, which are very difficult or even impossible to treat, are being seen across the EU, but particularly in the Baltic States.

"Two further diseases have very a high incidence, namely Chlamydia infection and campylobacteriosis, both with nearly 200 000 annually reported cases (known to be an underestimate). Even though they do not cause such serious disease as the priority diseases above, the sheer number of cases presents a huge challenge."


To end this very brief look at a comprehensive report, I mention here some population trends that have effect on disease incidence and prevalence in any country, as pointed out in the Introduction to this report: the ageing process, increasing migration, increased tourism and travel, globalization of trade in food and animals, among others. The chart immediately above shows the proportion of aged persons in the populations of the 28 countries measures. Note that Sweden seems highest, proportionately, in persons aged 80 and older.


The chart above shows the trend of immigrants (from outside EU) increasing their proportion of any given country's population.

A final chart, below, shows number of tourists in 2005, by country:

And, a final excerpt, this from the Foreword, by Markos Kyprianou, European Commissioner for Health:

"Perhaps the biggest challenge we face is the emergence of new microbes against which our defences are weak, or even non-existent. The threat of an influenza pandemic, which could be caused if one of the existing flu viruses were to mutate into a new super-virulent strain, has received much attention in the past two years. Rightly so. The world saw three such pandemics in the 20th century, and we know a 21st century pandemic could cause massive suffering and social disruption if we are not properly prepared. Pandemic preparedness is, and must remain, a priority for the EU. But deadly new microbes can also emerge in less spectacular ways. Healthcare-associated infections have become a major issue of concern in the EU, with many of these caused by new or emerging drug-resistant microbes. I note with concern that one in every 10 patients entering hospital in the EU will catch an infection there. Supporting action to address this problem will be a priority for the Commission and for ECDC in the coming year."
Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

Who were you, 10,000 years ago?

I have this notion that each of us has at least one talent, an inborn way that, if we were living 10,000 years ago, would be of specific value to the clan or group of cavemen or hunter-gatherers we belong to. I have read that our physical bodies are no different from those we had 10,000 years ago; that we were then just as human as we are now.

So who and what was I 10,000 year ago? I was not a hunter. I know a hunter, my oldest son Greg. He can make a bow and an arrow, can shoot a gun and release an arrow with a sure and steady hand. He can send a fly from a rod to the place where the fish will bite. He can steer a tugboat pushing a fuel and supply-laden barge through heavy seas in the waters surrounding Alaska. I do not have these talents.

I am a talker, an explainer of things, but I am not sure of what specific use this may be to the clan.

I do know where I am most of the time. I usually know where north is. I can hike an area I haven’t seen in ten years and remember key landmarks. I can find my out when lost, by looking at the lie of the land and imagine how the hills and valleys and creeks and streams relate to each other.

So, I will say I am a scout and a tracker. And a talker.

Who were you, 10,000 years ago?

Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

What will you probably die from?

Well, what country do you live in?

When seeking inspiration for the next blog entry, I sometimes go to my bookshelves to get ideas. So it is that I happened upon an old textbook (actually a replacement for the original I had lost): A Manual for the Control of Communicable Diseases in California, published by the California State Department of Public Health. This manual was a requirement for several of the courses I took at Earl Warren Hall on the Berkeley campus, which housed the School of Public Health from 1955 until its razing in 2007 due to its vulnerability to earthquakes. I attended the School from 1960 until receiving my MPH in 1965, with a year off for management training in a San Francisco hospital.

[Please click on any image to see it larger and more clearly]

As I perused the manual, nostalgically reviewing the exotic diseases it lists (e.g., Filariasis, Leishmaniasis, Schistosomiasis and, especially Coccidioidomycosis, the specialty of the School's then Dean, Charles E. Smith), I began to wonder what diseases in the world's countries account for the top three causes of death in each. I thought a look at this might tell us something interesting about the countries.

Image: Charles E. Smith, M.D., Dean, School of Public Health, UC Berkeley, 1951-1967)

So, I went to the Internet looking specifically for something from the World Health Organization that could help me. I found it here.

From the spreadsheet under the previous link (complicated, but navigable by the conscientious), I extracted data for the nine most populous countries that are also WHO member states, plus Germany and Sweden. I chose the latter two as representatives of the European Union which I have treated as a nation in other data analyses previously published in this blog. I chose Germany because it is the most populous nation in the EU; I chose Sweden because I live in Sweden. I added two more columns: a totals column for the eleven countries presented; and, a column for the totals of all the countries in the WHO (192 in all). Here is the extracted spreadsheet, showing estimated deaths per thousand population, by cause, in each of the subject countries and totals, year 2002:

Please click on the image in order to read it

I highlighted in different colors the primary, secondary and tertiary causes of death in each of the countries. The primary and secondary causes of death for all columns (i.e., for countries and totals) fell into four of eighteen rows of diseases: Infectious and Parasitic Diseases; Respiratory Infections; Malignant Neoplasms; and, Cardiovascular Diseases. Tertiary causes of death fell into three of these, plus Respiratory Diseases (non-infectious). Additionally, three countries had unique causes of death at the tertiary level: Neuropsychiactric conditions; Digestive Diseases; and, Unintentional Injuries.

  • Sweden: Neuropsychiactric Conditions
  • Germany: Digestive Diseases
  • Russian Federation: Unintentional Injuries

  • Aha! I thought. Here may be a chance to learn something interesting. So I dug a little deeper:

    Please click on the image in order to read it

    First, you will see that I have shown each of the three subject countries in separate sub-charts, surrounded by four other countries. These are to show context within the original WHO spreadsheet, and to provide comparisons.

    Second, I have added a column on the right showing my calculation of the average incidence of death for each listed cause, for all 192 WHO member countries. This is also to aid in comparisons.

    Third, I have highlighted the same numbers/values in this chart in the same gray or gray/violet color as I have in the first chart at the top of this page, in order to orient the viewer. I have also use the same color to highlight the corresponding numbers/values for the same cause in the “All Countries” column on the right, for comparison.

    Fourth, I have highlighted in yellow those one or more detailed causes underlying the original findings at the top of the page.

    Last, I have highlighted in beige/tan four cells in the Russian sub-chart because these are new observations, not mentioned in the first chart at the top of the page. Additionally I have highlighted in blue the more detailed causes underlying these new observations.

    Now to the findings:

    Image: Sweden's Prime Minister Fredrik Reinfeldt

    SWEDEN: The major element in Sweden's “Neuropsychiactric Conditions” is the incidence of “Alzheimer's and Other Dementias,” comprising 0.57 deaths of the 0.78 deaths per thousand in the original observation. Compare this to 0.06 for the All-countries average for this condition. Also, note that Switzerland also has a much higher than average incidence (0.40 deaths per thousand). I think it reasonable to assume at least two major factors at play here, for both Sweden and Switzerland: both are conscientious in their reporting, and their people are much older than the average in the world.

    Image: Angela Merkel, Chancellor of Germany

    Germany: The major element in Germany's “Digestive Diseases” is the incidence of “Cirrhosis of the Liver,” comprising 0.22 of the 0.51 deaths per thousand in year 2002. The average for all 192 countries is 0.13 deaths per thousand. Of the four alphabetically neighboring countries, only one other is above the average, namely Georgia at 0.32. It has been generally observed that there is a high correlation between alcohol consumption and cirrhosis, but one cannot draw absolute conclusions from this. It merely can point us in a direction for further study. Also, there may be environmental factors at play, such as chemical residues from heavy industry and agriculture, and previous wars.

    Image: Russian President Dmitri Medvedev

    Russia: All six of the detailed causes of death underlying Russia's “Unintentional Injuries” (1.59 deaths per thousand population) are comparatively high: Road Traffic Accidents (0.31); Poisonings (0.46); Falls (0.11); Fires (0.09); Drownings (0.12); and, “Other” (0.48). Compare each of these figures to the averages of all 192 countries, in the last column on the right.

    Image: Vladimir Putin, Immediate Past President, Russia

    In exposing this detail for Russia's "Unintentional Injuries", the detail underlying “Intentional Injuries” was exposed and seems also cause for remark. Russia’s reported Self-inflicted Injuries (suicides?), “violence” (murder?) and “War” are all much higher than the all-country averages, and also higher than any of the four neighbors in the chart. (Recall that this information is for year 2002). The only country in this sub-chart that approaches Russia’s number for “Violence” is Rwanda. All told, the “Injuries” general category containing both “unintentional” and “intentional” injuries is much higher than the all-countries average, and higher than any of the neighboring four countries on this sub-chart.

    There you have my little study. I will allow these data to speak for themselves, if you will be kind enough to assume I have made no transcription or mathematical errors. If you want to chase down the larger context of these data and all the provisos pertaining to methods of gathering and presenting them, go the the source.




    Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (2) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

    "...when Thomas Jefferson dined alone"

    The title of today's entry is from an address made, April 29,1962, by President John F. Kennedy in welcoming a group of Nobel Prize winners to a dinner in their honor at The White House. The extended quote is: "I think this is the most extraordinary collection of talent, of human knowledge, that has ever been gathered together at the White House — with the possible exception of when Thomas Jefferson dined alone."


    What ultimately brought me to this well-known quotation was my reading of a small and fascinating book, Autobiography of Thos. Jefferson. I bought this book, apparently second hand, many years ago and something told me I was prepared now to read it.

    There has been so much written about this great statesman, political philosopher, diplomat, inventor, amateur scientist, farmer, slaveholder and opponent of slavery, I can do no more than to refer you to others, and to offer some quotations.

    One thing he did not say, and I now correct myself on having misquoted him, is: "That government is best which governs least." It was Henry Thoreau, who paraphrased the motto of The United States Magazine: "The best government is that which governs least."

    Despite hundreds of volumes written by others about him, Jefferson's own recounting of his life takes but 100 pages in this small paperback. He starts it thus: "At the age of 77, I begin to make some memoranda, and state some recollections of dates and facts considering myself, for my own more ready reference, and for the information of my family."

    [Please click on all images for greater detail]

    I found it interesting that Jefferson served both in the legislature of the Virginia Commonwealth and as Governor of the successor State of Virginia. While a delegate to the legislature, he was chosen by his fellows to be on a "committee of correspondence" which met with other such committees in the other colonies to discuss their common interests including grievances against the British King and parliament. Much of Jefferson's work in this realm, before the Declaration of Independence (July 4, 1776), was as a lawyer in devising correct political positions with respect to the home country, even as he and others opposed many elements of Great Britain's rule.

    His biography dwelt for a while on his work in the development of Virginia's constitution, adopted June 12, 1776, which served as a template for much of what was devised and written for the U.S. Constitution, ratified June 21, 1788. This caused me to go to the Internet to find more information on this, which I present below.

    "A Bill of Rights is what the people are entitled to against every government, and what no just government should refuse, or rest on inference."

    Map showing The Louisiana Purchase, one of President Jefferson's legacies

    1. That all men are by nature equally free and independent, and have certain inherent rights, of which, when they enter into a state of society, they cannot, by any compact, deprive or divest their posterity; namely, the enjoyment of life and liberty, with the means of acquiring and possessing property, and pursuing and obtaining happiness and safety (Virginia Constitution, Bill of Rights, June 12, 1776).

    One of Jefferson's proudest achievements was the founding and the designing of The University of Virginia. "Educate and inform the whole mass of the people ... They are the only sure reliance for the preservation of our liberty ... Enlighten the people generally, and tyranny and oppressions of body and mind will vanish like evil spirits at the dawn of day."

    2. That all power is vested in, and consequently derived from, the people; that magistrates are their trustees and servants, and at all times amenable to them (Virginia Constitution, Bill of Rights, June 12, 1776).

    Thomas Jefferson's drawing of a macaroni machine and instructions for making pasta, ca. 1787.

    3. That government is, or ought to be, instituted for the common benefit, protection, and security, of the people, nation, or community; of all the various modes and forms of government that is best, which is capable of producing the greatest degree of happiness and safety, and is most effectually secured against the danger of maladministration; and that whenever any government shall be found inadequate or contrary to these purposes, a majority of the community hath an indubitable, unalienable, and indefeasible right, to reform, alter, or abolish it, in such manner as shall be judged most conducive to the publick weal (Virginia Constitution, Bill of Rights, June 12, 1776).

    "Question with boldness even the existence of a God; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason, than that of blind-folded fear ... I have recently been examining all the known superstitions of the world, and do not find in our particular superstition (Christianity) one redeeming feature. They are all alike founded on fables and mythology."

    Thomas Jefferson's design for a plow, ca. 1794.

    15. That no free government, or the blessing of liberty, can be preserved to any people but by a firm adherence to justice, moderation, temperance, frugality, and virtue, and by frequent recurrence to fundamental principles (Virginia Constitution, Bill of Rights, June 12, 1776).

    16. That religion, or the duty which we owe to our CREATOR, and the manner of discharging it, can be directed only by reason and conviction, not by force or violence; and therefore all men are equally entitled to the free exercise of religion, according to the dictates of conscience; and that it is the mutual duty of all to practice Christian forbearance, love, and charity, towards each other (Virginia Constitution, Bill of Rights, June 12, 1776).

    Jefferson's Home, "Monticello"

    "The strongest reason for the people to retain the right to keep and bear arms is, as a last resort, to protect themselves against tyranny in government ... The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants."

    "In the final 17 years of his life, Jefferson's major accomplishment was the founding (1819) of the University of Virginia at Charlottesville. He conceived it, planned it, designed it, and supervised both its construction and the hiring of faculty. The university was the last of three contributions by which Jefferson wished to be remembered; they constituted a trilogy of interrelated causes: freedom from Britain, freedom of conscience, and freedom maintained through education. On July 4, 1826, the 50th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, Jefferson died at Monticello." [Source]

    Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (1) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

    … a last glimpse of the land now being lost for ever

    ... Thus ends The Rings of Saturn by W.G. Sebald, one of the three books I present today. The others are: Thesiger by Michael Asher; and The Search for Sana by Richard Zimler, the latter book having been recently discussed in my book-reading group.

    I had made a promise to myself, and a bold statement to a fellow reader in my book group, that I would find a common theme among these seemingly disparate books, my having chosen them for different reasons. I intrepidly assert the title of this blog provides the connection among the books.


    The Rings of Saturn

    The introductory page before the table of contents has two quotations, one by Joseph Conrad, in French (Conrad is mentioned much in this book and occasionally in Thesiger), and one from Brockhaus Encyclopedia, as follows:

    “The rings of Saturn consist of ice crystals and probably meteorite particles describing circular orbits around the planet’s equator. In all likelihood these are fragments of a former moon that was too close to the planet and was destroyed by its tidal effect (→ Roche limit)”

    Such a beginning certainly presages the coming apart of things, as this singular book does provide evidence for, at least in The County of Suffolk, England.

  • The County of Suffolk, as located in the country of England

  • The author takes us on a journey through his county, starting in Norwich on a train to the coast bordering the North Sea, and thence generally along the coast on foot, sometimes dangerously. Later, having walked inland, he visits a friend, a writer and teacher, who lives in a house the author once lived in. He takes a taxi back to a previously visited town to think and write, as he had been doing all along this journey, then he traveled back home.

  • Places in Sussex County mentioned in the book, along with the author's musings on their historical and literary connections to many parts of the world [Please click on the image]

  • What, you may be asking, assuming you have read this far, is so interesting about all this?

    As the caption of the image immediately above implies, the author uses his travels to expose thoughts and memories stimulated by the places and people he visits. This section of England, or Great Britain in the larger picture, has had great forests, great industry (including the manufacture of silk), great homes and hotels, great resorts and, last, great airfields-staging areas for Great Britain's execution of its role in the Second World War. All are gone.

  • A former silk mill, now a museum, in the City of Derby
  • Not only are all these things and events gone, they have left a poisonous residue, killing the vast herring industry once centered here, among other insults. Nature has had a role in eating away at the vulnerable coastline, toppling cliffs and their made-made objects.

    As I read through this compelling book, I was taken on imaginary trips, accompanied by great detail, to: China (via an exposition on the origin of silk and its resultant world trade); The Enlightenment and many of its famous characters: the writers Gustav Flaubert, Algernon Swinburne, Edward Fitzgerald (The Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam), Joseph Conrad, Sir Thomas Browne, and Jorge Luis Borges, the latter's short story Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius being given much discussion.

    In the story, an encyclopedia article about a mysterious country called Uqbar is the first indication of Orbis Tertius, a massive conspiracy of intellectuals to imagine (and thereby create) a world: Tlön. "According to … a key tenet of the (several) philosophical schools of Tlön … the future exists only in the shape of our present apprehensions and hopes, and the past merely as memory. In a different view, the world and everything now living in it was created only moments ago, with its complete but illusory pre-history. A third school of thought...describes our earth as a cul-de-sac in the great city of God, a dark cave crowded with incomprehensible images, or a hazy aura surrounding a better sun. The advocates (in 'Tlön') of a fourth philosophy maintain that time has run its course and that this life is no more than a fading refection of an event beyond recall. We simply do not know how many of its possible mutations the world may have already gone through, or how much time, always assuming that it exists, remains." (Emphasis added).

    What has destroyed all that the author reminds us of, as the gravity of Jupiter has destroyed its former satellites, is, I believe, the Second World War. He was a German boy during the war, and later a life-long resident of England.

    And, the destroyer is also time, assuming it exists beyond the conceit of man.

    Thesiger

    Similarly, in Thesiger, a biography of the renown mid-20th century explorer Wilfrid Thesiger, the book ends with several quoted observations of the subject: "There is nothing to be cheerful about. Everything is wrong...There can be no future. It's inconceivable that there could be any human beings on the planet in a hundred years' time ... Not only transport but the interference with nature, you've got pollution and the threat to the ozone belt which means the heating up of the earth and the melting of the poles and half the world going under water."

  • Wilfrid Thesiger, whose father served in the British diplomatic corps, was born in Ethiopia in 1910. He returned as a young man to explore and hunt, and then traveled extensively in many parts of the Arabian Peninsula, and also in Iraq and Afghanistan. [Please click on the image]

  • Thesiger was given to hyperbole with native English speakers, spending most of his life having lived among and traveling with, by foot and camel, the native peoples of the mostly "untouched" lands he preferred to "civilization".

  • Wilfrid Thesiger
  • Continuing the ending quotes: "A hundred years ago there were no cars...Well in a hundred years what are we going to have? It won't be long before the Chinese will be demanding cars-you can't put all that pollution into the air and get away with it...I don't think development can be checked and that's why I think we're heading for disaster-it's just a matter of guessing whether it's fifty years or 100 years. I see absolutely no hope for the human species."

    As with his predecessor T.E. Lawrence, who Thesiger admired, he eschewed the intimate company of women, and sex altogether. He did like the company of young men who traveled with him as a sort of tribe, as did Lawrence. Thesiger's biographer interviewed him and followed in his footsteps to talk with many of the people Thesiger had traveled with, lending great credibility to Asher's portrait of the great explorer.

    As can be seen from the quotes at the beginning of this section, Thesiger saw civilization and, more precisely, its mechanization and industries, as the ruin of natural man, epitomized by the Bedu of the desert.


    Thesiger was the last person to travel to theretofore inaccessible places by foot and animal transport. He mourned the advent of the automobile. Wilfrid Thesiger died in 2003 at age 93 in England, having been forced to live there the last few years of his life because of ill health. He heart was, undoubtedly, in northern Kenya where he had last lived for many years, quite simply, among the native peoples there.

    “I cannot stand the lush green of the English countryside...Green should be a patch of cultivation, perhaps just a fig-tree, in contrast to an expanse of desert; then it becomes valuable.”

    The Search for Sana

    This is a complicated onion of a book. Just as you think you see the story whole, another layer peels off and you re-think what you may already have concluded about its trajectory. There are passages where you are not sure the characters are who they present themselves to be, and, in some cases, they aren't. It would be a disservice to the author and to your enjoyment of the book for me to reveal too much more, specifically, about it.

    How, then, to tie it in to the theme of this blog?

    It will not spoil your reading of the book for me to say the core of the story resides in a town in what is now Israel, where both Arabs and Jews live, although the action takes place in many places around the world: first, Australia, then, not in order, Brazil, Italy, England, New York and other places.

    The main characters (other than the narrator who appears to be the author himself) are two girls, one an Arab and one a Jew, who are soul-sisters growing up in a small place in Israel. The trajectory of their lives, together and apart, provide the basis for the story.

    Overlying the rest of the story is the constant theme of conflict between Arab and Jew, between Palestinian and Israeli, within and without the territory of Palestine/Israel.

    This conflict, without editorializing by the author/narrator except through the different viewpoints of his characters, is destroying the land and its peoples and generally poisoning the social and political atmosphere of the earth. This may seem a commonplace and non-extraordinary thing to say, but it is presented pungently by the author and, I feel, ties in to the theme of this blog.

    ---

  • The Langoliers or Inevitable Entropy, by George Grie [Please click on the image]
  • These three books are presenting the inevitability of decay, enhanced (I paraphrase Thesiger) by too many humans occupying too little space.

    Perhaps it is a simple matter of seeing entropy in action through what these books present. But this concept is insufficient. What these books present, each in its own way, is man's role in his and his world's undoing.
    Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

    Górecki, Penderecki, Pärt, Rautavaara, Vasks: New Music from the Baltic Region

    When I moved from San Jose, California to Sweden in mid-2002, I brought with me much recorded music, but only one of the above modern composers was included: Arvo Pärt. Without having looked into his background, I simply found his usually slow, sonorous and often mystical musical utterances immensely soulful and peace-bringing.

    Arvo Pärt

    Now that I live in one of the countries touched by the Baltic Sea, and having briefly visited the capital of Pärt's home country, Tallinn, I am now aware of his Estonian origins (he now lives in Berlin). I have, since then, bought more of his music and continue to derive much pleasure from listening. I believe his name is pronounce something like 'Pairt'.

    Einojuhani Rautavaara

    I hadn't heard of the other four, but have been made aware of them directly and indirectly through my friend in Uppsala, Johannes D. We have attended concerts together in Stockholm at Berwaldhallen, a concert hall named after the Swedish composer, Franz Berwald. In one of these concerts I was electrified by the performance of a composition of the Finnish composer Einojuhani Rautavaara, his violin concerto. I had heard of Rautavaara from Johannes, but hadn't explored his music before this concert. I now have many of his recorded compositions. His Cantus Arcticus is especially spell-binding.


    Countries bordering the Baltic Sea:

    * Denmark * Estonia
    * Finland * Germany
    * Latvia * Lithuania
    * Poland * Russia
    * Sweden

    In addition, countries providing drainage to the Baltic:

    * Belarus * Czech Rep.
    * Norway * Slovakia
    * Ukraine

    Peteris Vasks

    Another composer Johannes urged me to consider is Peteris Vasks, from Latvia. He almost ordered me to purchase Vasks's Violin Concerto, which I dutifully did and am forever grateful to Johannes for insisting. The concerto's title is Distant Light. I will let your imagination suggest how this might sound in the modern musical idiom. I have since acquired his Cello Concerto and Symphony No. 3.

    Two composers from Poland round out this report: Henryk Górecki and Krzysztof Penderecki. Since I have only recently discovered these two prolific composers, I will quote below from biographies on the Internet.

    Krzysztof Penderecki

    For many listeners, (Penderecki's) works call into question the location or existence of a border between "music" and "noise." Yet despite Penderecki's delightfully flagrant disregard for instrumental tradition, his music of the 1960s and early 1970s actually achieved wide-ranging popularity. For while the instrumental techniques propounded in these scores may have been consistently astonishing to audiences, Penderecki's underlying musical rhetoric of exaggerated dramatic gestures, coupled with an atmosphere of brooding, edgy intensity, were much more familiar. In this respect, it comes as no surprise to encounter Penderecki's music of this period in films such as Stanley Kubrick's 2001 and The Shining. His weird but theatrical soundworld seems tailor-made for movie directors seeking to evoke unease within the context of carefully structured dramatic scenes. Indeed, the sheer power of the musical gestures Penderecki fashions from his battery of odd sounds - what Professor Thomas aptly characterised as a "broadstroke approach" to composition - carries the listener (or viewer) along, no matter how foreign or disorientating the immediate landscape might be. (Source).

    Henryk Górecki

    Górecki's music covers a variety of styles, but tends towards relative harmonic and rhythmical simplicity. He is considered to be a founder of the New Polish School, and his first works were in the avant-garde style of Pierre Boulez and other serialists. During the late 1960s and early 1970s, Górecki progressively moved away from his early career as radical modernist, and began to compose with a more traditional, romantic mode of expression.

    Górecki's most popular piece is his Third Symphony, subtitled Symphony of Sorrowful Songs (Symfonia piesni zalosnych). Slow and contemplative, the three movements are composed for orchestra and solo soprano. The words of the first movement are from a 15th century lament; the words of the second from a teenage girl, Helena Blazusiak, written on the wall of a Gestapo prison cell in Zakopane to invoke the protections of the Virgin Mary; the third movement uses a folk song.

    When placing Górecki in the context of the history of modern art, commentators usually compare his work with such composers as Messiaen, and Ives. He has said that he feels kindred with such figures as Bach, Mozart, and Haydn, though he feels most affinity towards Schubert, particularly in terms of tonal design and treatment of basic materials.

    Since Górecki's move away from serialism and dissonance in the 1970s, he is frequently compared to composers such as Arvo Pärt, John Tavener, and Giya Kancheli. (Source).

    A final note: I have sometimes wondered whether the golden age of music from, say, the 16th through the 19th century, could ever return--in newer forms of course. I speculate that the creative energies previously quashed or directed by the Soviet empire's leaders has, since 1990, been loosed in wonderful ways for our great pleasure. In the case of Finland's Rautavaara, he is carrying on in the great tradition of his predecessor, Jean Sibelius.


    Jean Sibelius, 1865-1957

    I am sure I have overlooked, or have omitted due to space considerations, many other fine composers, about which I would love to hear from you.

    Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

    Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900) on God, Christianity, The Enlightenment, Words. Rationality, Science, Language, Truth, and Everything

    Somewhere along the line I heard enough about Nietzsche to associate him with the phrase “God is dead,” but I didn’t know if he was supposed to be celebrating this assertion or decrying it. [Click the link under the phrase to find the answer].

    In the early 1980s my late former father-in-law declared something to the effect that I was spouting or paraphrasing Nietzsche! I didn’t immediately follow through on this, being so deep into my former career.

    About a year ago, I happened across a little book: Nietzsche and Postmodernism by Dave Robinson, published by “Icon Books.” As I continue to re-read it I am brought back, by Nietzsche’s assertions, to the lessons of Alan Watts, a one-time Anglican priest and great teacher of Eastern ways, especially The Tao, Buddhism and Buddhism's evolution to Zen.

    According to the author, Dave Robinson, Nietzsche said:

  • Human language has no coherent correspondence with the ‘real’ world. Language can never be ‘literal’ in the sense that it can describe the reality of the world to us.
  • All language is inevitably metaphorical. Social and intellectual life depends on common consent, and this gives birth to a shared consensual reality in which concepts such as “knowledge” and “truth” inevitably emerge. These concepts are then reinforced by language. Such limited human ‘truths’ make social life possible. Unfortunately, they can also lead to a futile hunt for spurious and illusory metaphysical ‘truths’ that don’t exist.
  • Logic and classification both originate from our need to control and dominate the world The undoubted usefulness of logic hypnotizes human beings into believing they can use it to obtain transcendent or scientific truths. Logic is a very useful survival tool, but that is all it is.
  • Words are useful to us because (they can) simplify and ‘freeze’ the chaos and complexities of our surroundings, but that is all they can do.

    [Freiderich Nietzsche, right]

    “Words, as is well known, are the great foes of reality.”
    —Joseph Conrad

    “Words are, of course, the most powerful drug used by mankind.”
    —Rudyard Kipling

    “Words are dwarfs, but examples are giants.”
    —Swiss-German Proverb

    As an aspiring writer I have bemoaned the inability of words to describe the totality and essence of the reality I perceive. I reckon this is why we need art, poetry and music—none is necessarily “logical.”